First off, I gave into temptation and downloaded the Pinkerton deluxe. I have every intention of purchasing it the day it comes out, so I'd rather not hearing any criticisms regarding this.Before I…Continue
"Overall I think the package is great. The criticisms I'd offer:
The b-sides and outtakes are sequenced poorly. They're scattered over different discs instead of continuously flowing.
You Won't Get With Me Tonight is the SFTBH…"
"I knew the "you should be happy with what you got" comments would start coming in but let me say this:
As I said,I am, for the most part happy with how this was put together, maybe even more so than the Blue Album Deluxe, aside from the…"
"I'm more than happy. There are 9 non album tracks/songs on there, 2 of which up until recently we didn't even know existed.
The demo for Getchoo is also a gem. I love Matt's bassline in the song, so much stronger than that of the…"
"I definitely would have loved live versions of Across the Sea and falling for you, but I am very happy.. By the way, did anyone notice that the lyric book is missing lyrics for El Scorcho. Just happen to notice that."
"The live versions aren't bad, it's just that they have been available for years now. I first downloaded the Sonic Sessions and Shorecrest High School sessions back in 2002.
If they were going to release stuff that we already had, I rather…"
"i had commented earlier that i wasn't pleased with all the live stuff.. but the sonic session stuff is great. i loved it. and the alternate take of butterfly put a tear in my eye.. only thing i didn't like was el scorcho at reading... i…"