Only in Dreams ftw
Haunt You Every Day, Pig, You Won't Get With Me Tonight, We Are All On Drugs, Why Bother?, I Don't Want Your Loving.
All good choices, imo.
I would say OID, just to make the guests sit still for 8 minutes.
I really like "Pig" as an idea. such a tragic love song.
surprised no one suggested "Tragic Girl", lol. My favorite weezer break up song