with the new song survey up, i wanted to point out that over at allthingsweezer.com i've been manually doing the same thing over the last two or so years. following are the most recent results. i'm interested to see what the official poll gets compared to this one.

 

Across The Sea (98.28%)
Say It Ain't So (98.09%)
Only In Dreams (97.87%)
Falling For You (97.26%)
The Good Life (97.05%)
Buddy Holly (96.66%)
Susanne (96.21%)
El Scorcho (96.01%)
You Gave Your Love To Me Softly (95.90%)
Longtime Sunshine (Demo) (95.83%)
[b]Tragic Girl (95.63%)[/b]
My Name Is Jonas (95.32%)
Holiday (95.21%)
You Gave Your Love To Me Softly (Soundtrack Version) (95.04%)
Pink Triangle (94.85%)
Tired of Sex (94.73%)
Devotion (94.71%)
I Just Threw Out The Love Of My Dreams (93.48%)
[b]Getting Up And Leaving (93.37%)[/b]
Blast Off!/Who You Callin' B****? (93.18%)
Undone (The Sweater Song) (93.13%)
Pig (Demo) (92.90%)
No One Else (92.29%)
Waiting On You (92.23%)
Jamie (91.69%)
[b]Mykel And Carli (Blue Sessions Version) (91.45%)[/b]
The World Has Turned and Left Me Here (91.40%)
Butterfly (91.28%)
Walt Disney (91.11%)
[b]Butterfly (Alternate Version) (90.98%)[/b]
You Won't Get With Me Tonight (90.82%)
Superfriend (90.31%)
Pig (90.07%)
Why Bother? (90.00%)

Miss Sweeney (89.99%)
Rosemary (89.63%)
Mykel And Carli (B-Side Version) (89.40%)
[b]Long Time Sunshine (Coda Mix) (88.97%)[/b]
Lover In The Snow (88.95%)
In The Garage (87.84%)
The Purification Of Water (87.52%)
Autumn In Jayne (87.34%)
I'll Think About You (86.73%)
Hot Tub (86.10%)
Wanda, You're My Only Love (85.95%)
Surf Wax America (85.89%)
Hey M' Darlin' (85.58%)
Fun Time (85.56%)
No Other One (85.42%)
I Don't Want To Let You Go (Demo) (85.07%)
Getchoo (84.13%)
The Greatest Man That Ever Lived (83.91%)
Baby (83.80%)
Run Away (83.51%)
Can't Stop Partying (Demo) (82.87%)
My Brain Is Workin' Overtime (82.83%)
Thief, You've Taken All That Was Me (82.22%)
1,000 Years (82.20%)
Chess (82.05%)
Sheila Can Do It (81.93%)
Unspoken (81.71%)
American Girls (81.65%)
Crazy One (81.07%)
Let's Sew Our Pants Together (81.00%)
[b]I Swear It's True (Pinkerton Version) (80.68%)[/b]
I Can Love (80.66%)
Lullaby For Wayne (80.65%)
Perfect Situation (80.65%)
Everybody Wants A Chance To Feel All Alone (80.58%)
The Prettiest Girl In The Whole Wide World (80.39%)
I Was Made For You (80.16%)

[b]Trampoline (79.48%)[/b]
Run Over By A Truck (79.37%)
I Don't Want To Let You Go (Album Version) (79.11%)
Pork And Beans (79.02%)
The Angel And The One (78.84%)
O-Girl (78.65%)
Time Flies (78.57%)
Hang On (78.48%)
Hash Pipe (78.38%)
Paperface (Full Band Version) (78.38%)
Island In The Sun (78.13%)
Ruling Me (77.80%)
[b]Blowin' My Stack (77.43%)[/b]
Private Message (77.25%)
Broken Arrows (77.04%)
Don't Let Go (AOL Version) (76.88%)
Trippin' Down The Freeway (76.82%)
Burndt Jamb (76.81%)
The Christmas Song (76.58%)
The Story Of My Life (76.48%)
Cold And Damp (76.11%)
Paperface (Home Demo) (76.08%)
High Up Above (Organ Version) (75.98%)
O Girlfriend (75.00%)
I Swear It's True (Blue Era Version) (74.71%)
The Organ Player (74.51%)
Mad Kow (Summer Songs Of 2000 Version) (74.47%)
Mad Kow (EA5D Version) (74.35%)
Photograph (74.34%)
Dreamin' (74.30%)
I Was Scared (73.98%)
High Up Above (Maladroit Version) (73.81%)
Don't Let Go (73.74%)
(If You're Wondering If I Want You To) I Want You To (73.34%)
Sunshine O (73.23%)
Hey Domingo! (73.17%)
Sandwiches Time (73.09%)
This Is Such A Pity (72.98%)
We Go Together (HBO Reverb Version) (72.92%)
Haunt You Everyday (71.85%)
The Prettiest Girl In The Whole Wide World (Demo) (71.60%)
The Other Way (71.53%)
367 (70.82%)
So Low (70.62%)
Lemonade (70.61%)
Peace And Quiet (70.50%)
We Go Together (Studio Version) (70.47%)
Preacher's Son (70.42%)

Hold Me (69.90%)
It's Easy (69.85%)
Prodigy Lover (69.17%)
Faith In The Light (69.10%)
Cygnus X-1 (68.75%)
Fall Together (68.67%)
Starlight (68.62%)
All My Friends Are Insects (68.57%)
Peace (68.51%)
Smile (68.46%)
Slob (Summer Songs Of 2000 Version) (68.37%)
Slob (68.31%)
I Want To Be Something (68.22%)
Keep Fishin' (Single Version) (67.87%)
Dope Nose (67.84%)
Dope Nose (Summer Songs Of 2000 Version) (67.78%)
Living Without You (67.69%)
Too Late To Try (67.64%)
I Want To Take You Home Tonight  (67.48%)
Slave (67.43%)
Modern Dukes (Summer Songs of 2000 Version) (67.26%)
Teenage Victory Song (67.08%)
Superstar (Summer Songs of 2000 Version) (67.04%)
Cryin' And Lonely (66.76%)
Don't Pick On Me (66.36%)
Superstar (EA5D Version) (66.30%)
Modern Dukes (EA5D Version) (66.19%)
The Spider (65.99%)
Simple Pages (65.85%)
Knock-Down Drag-Out (65.74%)
Death & Destruction (65.44%)
[b]Turning Up The Radio (64.85%)[/b]
The Underdogs (64.83%)
Pardon Me (64.73%)
Trainwrecks (64.27%)
December (64.10%)
She Who Is Militant (64.04%)
The Damage In Your Heart (63.85%)
Keep Fishin' (63.72%)
Saturday Night (63.64%)
[b]I'm A Robot (63.46%)[/b]
I Need Some Touch (63.33%)
Your Sister (63.00%)
Running Man (62.59%)
Put Me Back Together (62.48%)
My Day Is Coming (62.34%)
Island In The Sun (Demo) (62.27%)
Brightening Day (62.21%)
The Victor (62.11%)
I Do (62.02%)
Queen Of Earth (61.97%)
Let It All Hang Out (61.20%)
The Dawn (60.82%)
[b]Everyone (60.76%)[/b]
Lullaby (60.73%)
Glorious Day (60.69%)
Love Explosion (60.32%)
Smart Girls (60.31%)
[b]I Don't Want Your Loving (60.18%)[/b]
Always (60.11%)
New Joint (60.00%)

Untenable (59.65%)
Brave New World (59.59%)
Take Control (59.52%)
[b]The Odd Couple (59.16%)[/b]
Fontana (58.68%)
King (58.52%)
I Hear Bells (58.14%)
I'll Stay Right Here (57.97%)
Beverly Hills (57.95%)
On The Edge (57.93%)
The Girl Got Hot (57.60%)
[b]Losing My Mind (57.18%)[/b]
Can't Stop Partying (56.54%)
I'm Your Daddy (56.34%)
Heart Songs (56.56%)
Mr. Taxman (56.42%)
Little Sister (55.72%)
Listen Up (55.56%)
[b]Autopilot (55.02%)[/b]
[b]Unbreak My Heart (55.00%)[/b]
Thought I Knew (55.43%)
Crab (55.27%)
Memories (54.63%)
Troublemaker (54.44%)
Booby Trap (54.35%)
American Gigolo (53.88%)
Ev'ry Nite (53.57%)
Diamond Rings (53.39%)
Seafaring Jamb (53.32%)
How Long? (53.18%)
Little Songs (52.57%)
Sugar Booger (52.55%)
Freak Me Out (52.45%)
Turn Me 'Round (52.19%)
Misstep (51.88%)
[b]Yellow Camaro (51.80%)[/b]
Automatic (51.33%)
Mansion Of Cardboard (50.57%)
Sacrifice (50.32%)

Acapulco (Maladroit Version) (49.17%)
Where's My Sex? (48.93%)
Acapulco (EA5D Version) (48.83%)
Comin' Home (Left My Broken Heart In Carolina) (48.25%)
Represent (Single Version) (47.92%)
The Rat Race (46.88%)
Mo' Beats (46.22%)
Love Is The Answer (Laid Back Mix) (45.78%)
Everybody Go Away (45.10%)
Everybody Get Dangerous (44.54%)
Ain't Got Much Time (44.41%)
Possibilities (44.22%)
Oh Lisa (43.81%)
Christmas Celebration (43.42%)
Space Rock (43.22%)
I Don't Want Your Loving (Demo) (42.70%)
Can't Stop Partying (Coconut Teaser Mix) (42.67%)
Represent (Rocked Out Mix) (41.99%)
I Wanna Know (41.40%)
[b]Outta Here (41.06%)[/b]
Porcupine (40.78%)
We Are All On Drugs (40.51%)

Your Room (39.89%)
Get Me Some (39.77%)
Change The World (39.67%)
In The Mall (38.57%)
My Best Friend (37.23%)
Love Is The Answer (Album Version) (36.35%)
Serendipity (33.87%)
The Story Is Wrong (32.58%)
Zep Jamb (32.58%)

This Is The Way (29.53%)
Cold Dark World (25.82%)
Reason To Worry (24.50%)
Cold Dark World (Rivers Lead Vocals) (22.19%)

Views: 155

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I rated it a 5, gonna spoil that for you, sorry.

Nathan said:
Scorcho should have 100%
Disagree with many scores up thurr.
I don't get why Brightening Day wasn't on the list...it's such an awesome song!  Weezer fans are so critical though... how are more than half these songs less than 70%?  If this was graded like a school, most of the songs are failing.  How can people consider themselves fans when they dislike or hate the majority of their music?  I for one rated every song a 7 or higher, with the exception of maybe 4 or 5 songs.

who doesn't?


runnersdialzero said:

Disagree with many scores up thurr.
i can't believe all of the maladroit and make believe demos were so low. Those songs are awesome!!!

the allthingsweezer boards are made up of 90's only weezer songs (sure there are exceptions, but for the most part, haters).

 

And Brightening Day should have been on that list.  One of my favorite =w= tunes.


Farkas said:

i can't believe all of the maladroit and make believe demos were so low. Those songs are awesome!!!
i feel the same way. that's probably my favorite era of the band (Green to EA5D)

Farkas said:
i can't believe all of the maladroit and make believe demos were so low. Those songs are awesome!!!
I'm surprised that paperface only has 78%
This is pretty accurate, but there are some songs towards the bottom that I love!! Then again I love every song except for "Love Is The Answer" *shivers*
It is there!

Mike Sobek said:
I don't get why Brightening Day wasn't on the list...it's such an awesome song!  Weezer fans are so critical though... how are more than half these songs less than 70%?  If this was graded like a school, most of the songs are failing.  How can people consider themselves fans when they dislike or hate the majority of their music?  I for one rated every song a 7 or higher, with the exception of maybe 4 or 5 songs.
I'm happy with the fact that In The Mall is low on this list. Such a stupid song.
i didn't read any of this past the description

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Weezer Bootlegs

SOCIAL

  • Weezer Links

Weezer Mailing List

Music

Loading…

© 2014   Created by Weezer.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Offline

Live Video