Pinkerton Deluxe, B-Sides/Previously Unreleased Material, and a Man
So for long-time fans of Pinkerton (such as myself) it is perhaps blasphemy to even consider toying with what is viewed by many as a nigh-perfect track list. The album flows beautifully, as is.
That being said, I've recently wondered why certain material from that era never made the album, and wondered further, "If I were limited to 10 songs and had the option of replacing one or two of them with other songs from that time period, what would I choose?"
Still blasphemy, yet still pondering it. I have noticed that Waiting On You has been among many fans' favorites for quite some time, and Tragic Girl is magnificent.
If you could fiddle with the 10-song track list, would you replace anything? If so, what and why?
That being said, I've recently wondered why certain material from that era never made the album, and wondered further, "If I were limited to 10 songs and had the option of replacing one or two of them with other songs from that time period, what would I choose?"
Still blasphemy, yet still pondering it. I have noticed that Waiting On You has been among many fans' favorites for quite some time, and Tragic Girl is magnificent.
If you could fiddle with the 10-song track list, would you replace anything? If so, what and why?
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by hintofcoolness on -
OH YES, I FORGOT.
-
Permalink Reply by Radioactive on -
1. Tired of Sex
2. Getchoo
3. No Other One
4. Why Bother?
5. Across the Sea
6. The Good Life
7. El Scorcho
8. Pink Triangle
9. Falling for You
10. Tragic Girl
11. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by hintofcoolness on
-
you missed the limited-to-10-songs-part, therein lies the challenge
Radioactive said:1. Tired of Sex
2. Getchoo
3. No Other One
4. Why Bother?
5. Across the Sea
6. The Good Life
7. El Scorcho
8. Pink Triangle
9. Falling for You
10. Tragic Girl
11. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by Sdawg on -
1. Tragic Girl
2. Tired of Sex
3. Why Bother
4. No Other One
5. Waiting on You
6. Pink Triangle
7. Across the Sea
8. El Scorcho (or falling for you)
9. Longtime Sunshine
10. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by Sdawg on
-
sorry?
j-biebs said:you have no sense of tracklist pacing whatsoever.
Stefan said:1. Tragic Girl
2. Tired of Sex
3. Why Bother
4. No Other One
5. Waiting on You
6. Pink Triangle
7. Across the Sea
8. El Scorcho (or falling for you)
9. Longtime Sunshine
10. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by Philip Taylor Jr. on -
This is actually how I pictured the track list after having heard Tragic Girl and thinking it really should've been on the album. "Ain't no butterfly girl" seems to put it logically right before Butterfly to me.
Radioactive said:1. Tired of Sex
2. Getchoo
3. No Other One
4. Why Bother?
5. Across the Sea
6. The Good Life
7. El Scorcho
8. Pink Triangle
9. Falling for You
10. Tragic Girl
11. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by runnersdialzero on -
The only reasonable solution is two seperate albums.
-
Permalink Reply by 870923857 on -
1. Blast Off!
2. You Won't Get W/ Me Tonight
3. Falling for You
4. Getchoo
5. Tired of Sex
6. Superfriend
7. The Good Life
8. Love of My Dreams
9. Longtime Sunshine
10. Butterfly
-
Permalink Reply by hintofcoolness on
-
Agreed :P
runnersdialzero said:The only reasonable solution is two seperate albums.
© 2013 Created by Weezer.
