It's pretty self explanatory. Rank Weezer's albums (from your favorite to your least favorite).


My list goes as follows:


Pinkerton

Blue

Red (Deluxe)/Hurley [tied]

Maladroit 

Green

Make Believe

Raditude 



I struggled big-time (I'm talking hours of deliberation here, people--not even kidding, it's borderline pathetic really) with the placement of Red and Hurley. In the end, I decided, consistently speaking, that I think I like Hurley better. To me, it really is the most CONSISTENTLY good Weezer release since Blue/Pinkerton. But on to Red, or Red (Deluxe) rather. To be honest, the reason why I place so much value on Red and like it so much, I'd say, is 60% because of the 4 bonus tracks included on the deluxe edition. Without "Miss Sweeney", "Pig", "The Spider, and "King" included in said deluxe edition, I would've known FOR SURE that Hurley would be ahead of Red. Similarly, let's just say for a moment, that if those 4 tracks were included in Red, not as bonus tracks but as original releases, it would be the other way around, once again, I'd know FOR SURE that Red would be ahead of Hurley. 


Oh Lord. Sorry for the rambling. And possible boredom. And definite confusion. 


To make a longer than necessary story short, when it comes down to it, I honestly cannot, FOR THE LIFE OF ME, decide between the two albums and that is why, as you see, Red (Deluxe) and Hurley are tied on my list. It's those damn bonus tracks of Red (Deluxe), man, I'm telling you! I. Just can't. Get over. Them.


Tags: albums, favorite, weezer

Views: 81

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Pinkerton
The Blue Album
Hurley
The Green Album
Death To False Metal
Make Believe
The Red Album
Maladroit
Raditude
My current list...

Blue
Pinkerton
Green
Red
Death
Hurley
Maladroit
Raditude
Make Believe
DTFM
Hurley
Raditude
Make Believe
Blue
Maladroit
Green
Red
Pinkerton
Wow I feel special and proud (that's right I said proud) to have Pinkerton on the bottom of my list. LIVE TO BE DIFFERENT!
Pinkerton Deluxe (Getting Up and Leaving/Tragic Girl, re-recording of I Swear it's true and B-sides give reason for the deluxe mention)
Blue Deluxe (I Swear It's True and b-sides again)
Maladroit/Hurley/Make Believe (can't decide which is better, all tied)
Red Deluxe
Death to False Metal/Green
Raditude
Pinkerton
Blue
Red
Hurley
Green
Make Believe
Maladroit
Raditude
Blue
Pinkerton
Make believe
Green
Maladroit
Red
Hurley
Raditude
Blue Album
Pinkerton
Green Album
Maladroit
Raditude
Death to False Metal
Red Album
Hurley
Make Believe

Although I personally love the Alone albums, but thats just me

EDIT, I don't hate Make Believe, i actually love it, i just couldn't decide where to put it. (All the other ones just kick the s*** out of it)
Good thing there's only about thirteen "Rank The Albums" threads.
Blue/Pinkerton
Green
Red
Maladroit

Umm.. i can't go on, it's too hard.
Pinkerton
Blue
Make Believe
Hurley
Red
DTFM
Green
Raditude
Maladroit
I'm going by my ratings on RYM; most of them have the same rating, so I'll just go by which one I'd be more likely to listen to.

Blue/Pinkerton (tie)
Maladroit
Raditude (I don't want to hear it)
Make Believe (same here)
Green
Hurley
DTFM (which I haven't even HEARD yet, but I know it can't be worse than...)



........... Red (standard OR deluxe; and, again, I don't want to hear it)
1. The Red Album
2. The Blue Album
3. Make Believe
4. Raditude
5. The Green Album
6. Hurley
7. Pinkerton
8. Death To False Metal
9. Maladroit

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Weezer Bootlegs

SOCIAL

  • Weezer Links

Weezer Mailing List

Music

Loading…

© 2014   Created by Weezer.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Offline

Live Video