Best Album

So, which one is it? Blue? Green? Pinkerton? Raditude? Red? DTFM? Make Believe? Whaddaya think, and why?

I've listened to the Blue Albumso much, it's been such a big part of my life for so long, the soundtrack for so many memories. Gonna have to say it's Blue. How about you?

0 members like this

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Aaron Charrell Ivy on January 6, 2011 at 7:34am

i personally like the red album the best

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Hugh Lovric on January 6, 2011 at 9:28am

i like the green album the most and the ss2k songs are also my favourite

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Next big thing on January 6, 2011 at 10:19am

My top three right now are Make believe, Green, and Hurley.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by David J. Stepp (DJS92491) on January 6, 2011 at 10:22am

Okay, this is weird. We both have the same last name. lol

Regardless, Pinkerton.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by aO - r3tH>VHs H6i3l u3b - Bs on January 9, 2011 at 9:48pm

Not necessarily saying it's the best.. But justice is deserved for the timeless, soul-bearing, ego-exploding, excellence of Make Believe.

Again, I don't believe it to be so; but I think every band should be judged on their perceived 'low-lights' as well as the classics. I love TBA and Pinkerton... I also love Red, Rad, and Hurley. But the hate for Make Believe is just not fair. It's Weezer, coming to terms with being Weezer. It's Rivers, sounding more sincere and creatively in sync than any self-indulging, unapologetic, Rock Star could pretend to be. The Why Bother, the The Good Life Rivers would have died of insecurity before releasing songs like Damage.. Pardon Me.. Other Side.. Freak Me... Into the Dog-Eat-Dog-Bites-The-Hand-That-Feeds- music press (cough*pitchfork*).

Maybe someone can clear it up for me.. Say if MB was released with louder guitars.. Dirtier bass.. Say It was a bit less forgiving lyrically. A little added self-deprecation. What then?

That being said... The quality of the recordings themselves are incredible given the unorthodox production.

Actually, I'm convinced!
MB #1

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Jeremy on January 9, 2011 at 9:53pm

I love all weezer, because I have great amounts of respect for the guys as musicians. I personally like Pinkerton the best. It is simply a masterpiece and I would have died to see it live yesterday

Benjamin L. Shachter said:

Not necessarily saying it's the best.. But justice is deserved for the timeless, soul-bearing, ego-exploding, excellence of Make Believe. Again, I don't believe it to be so; but I think every band should be judged on their perceived 'low-lights' as well as the classics. I love TBA and Pinkerton... I also love Red, Rad, and Hurley. But the hate for Make Believe is just not fair. It's Weezer, coming to terms with being Weezer. It's Rivers, sounding more sincere and creatively in sync than any self-indulging, unapologetic, Rock Star could pretend to be. The Why Bother, the The Good Life Rivers would have died of insecurity before releasing songs like Damage.. Pardon Me.. Other Side.. Freak Me... Into the Dog-Eat-Dog-Bites-The-Hand-That-Feeds- music press (cough*pitchfork*).

Maybe someone can clear it up for me.. Say if MB was released with louder guitars.. Dirtier bass.. Say It was a bit less forgiving lyrically. A little added self-deprecation. What then?

That being said... The quality of the recordings themselves are incredible given the unorthodox production.

Actually, I'm convinced!
MB #1

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by David J. Stepp (DJS92491) on January 9, 2011 at 9:55pm

I like Other Side from Make Believe. I also very much enjoy Scar Tissue and Californication. :)

Benjamin L. Shachter said:

Not necessarily saying it's the best.. But justice is deserved for the timeless, soul-bearing, ego-exploding, excellence of Make Believe.

Again, I don't believe it to be so; but I think every band should be judged on their perceived 'low-lights' as well as the classics. I love TBA and Pinkerton... I also love Red, Rad, and Hurley. But the hate for Make Believe is just not fair. It's Weezer, coming to terms with being Weezer. It's Rivers, sounding more sincere and creatively in sync than any self-indulging, unapologetic, Rock Star could pretend to be. The Why Bother, the The Good Life Rivers would have died of insecurity before releasing songs like Damage.. Pardon Me.. Other Side.. Freak Me... Into the Dog-Eat-Dog-Bites-The-Hand-That-Feeds- music press (cough*pitchfork*).

Maybe someone can clear it up for me.. Say if MB was released with louder guitars.. Dirtier bass.. Say It was a bit less forgiving lyrically. A little added self-deprecation. What then?

That being said... The quality of the recordings themselves are incredible given the unorthodox production.

Actually, I'm convinced!
MB #1